I have a letter from the House of Commons in response to an email I sent to my MP, David Mowat. Before you read it, have a look at the scale of the Big Society Forest Sell Off.
My email:
22nd December 2010
Dear David
Don’t do it – Do not sell our forests. We have not given this government permission to do this.
We will fight to save our forests.
I don’t have any children and do not plan on having any, but your children and grandchildren will suffer for a forest sell off. It’s idiotic that a group of millionaires in a room in London can decide they will sell off all, not just some but all, of our forests.
This email registers my anger at the stupidity of a government that will sell off our forests.
Karen Wilde
South Warrington Constituent
I admit I was very angry when I wrote the email – this issue does that to me. But what has made me angrier is the response Mr Mowat sent. Here it is:
6th January 2011
Dear Mrs Wilde [I'm not a Mrs, but he probably doesn't care about that either]
Thank you for contacting me about deforestation. [I didn't, I contacted him about selling the forests in England]
The Secretary of State for DEFRA, the Rt. Hon Caroline Spelman MP has taken a very firm stance on deforestation. [Yes, she promised £100,000,000 for overseas forestry protection] She has made clear that deforestation is a critical issue for the planet both in terms of the environmental impact and the economic impact.
Forests are home to untold species of plants and animals and they all have a role. [Well, duh!] Extinction through loss of habitat and the overall structure of our ecosystems and our environment grow weaker as a result. Economies suffer too – the global cost of one year’s worth of deforestation is estimate to be between $2 and $5 trillion. This is the equivalent of two financial crashes a year. [Oh, you mean like the next one we are walking in to with the programme of cuts]
The Copenhagen Accord confirmed that the UN programme on reducing emissions from deforestation and forest degradation otherwise know [sic] as REDD+ was a priority.
The UK’s responsible timber trade has led the way in promoting legal and sustainable timber. The European Parliament voted to adopt Due Diligence Regulation which shut the door firmly in the face of illegal timber entering the EU markets.
I believe that the firm stance taken by the Government so far on deforestation is very positive, however there is much further to go on this important issue.
Thank you once again for taking the time to contact me about this. [I DIDN'T!!!]
Best wishes
David Mowat MP
Warrington South
If you follow me on Twitter you know how much I go on about #SaveOurForests.
This letter does not mention anything about the proposed sell off of England’s publicly owned forest land (which constitutes 33% of our forested areas).
This letter does not mention anything about the Public Bodies Bill Clauses 17 and 18 that will give MPs the right to sell the forests without our consent.
This letter does not mention anything about the Natural Environment White Paper due out later this spring.
This letter is not worth the paper (made from wood pulp) that it is written on.
David Mowat MP, shame on you.
Now – GO AND SIGN THE PETITION to stop the sell off of our remaining publicly owned forests, before it’s too late.
Now – Get in touch with your MP and object to Clauses 17 and 18 of the Public Bodies Bill, before it’s too late.
This is not for me – this is for your children, your grandchildren and the future of biodiversity in England.
I have written about this before if you’re interested.






[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Mr Uku, Karen Wilde, Karen Wilde, Karen Wilde, Karen Wilde and others. Karen Wilde said: I agree world deforestation is an issue – but that's not what I was talking about http://bit.ly/er8byK #SaveOurForests [...]
I had a similar experience when corresponding with my local MP, Grant Shapps, about banking reform. I wrote (e-mail) to him in good faith, in the hope that he would investigate the issues involved and/or at the very least read the joint submission of The New Economics Foundation (NEF) and Positive Money (PM) to the Independent Banking Commission (ICB).
I received two duplicate form responses from two different adjutants. I doubt very much Mr. Shapps ever read my letter, or the NEF/PM submission to the ICB. Which is a shame, as this is an important issue and would be nice to think our politicians (who cannot be expected to be experts in all fields) would welcome a little guidance when its offered to them by their electorate and/or experts.
If when, later this year, the ICB releases its recommendations and they are ignored or glossed over by the current regime in Whitehall I shall be very angry. That will be the last nail in the coffin of my hope for a democratic settlement under the current form of government.
Kind Regards,
Lee Hyde.
It’s incredible how MPs fail to address the concerns of the constituents they are paid to represent.
Our current form of government is no longer sustainable if MPs do not listen to or regard the thoughts of the electorate.
Thanks for your comments Lee.
People often forget that out current form of government was not arrived at on the grounds of philosophy and righteousness, but rather successive revolts and rebellions that have granted further freedoms. The history of British democracy is not one of constant struggle and grudging settlements, and not honourable politicians working for the good of their people.
Are there any honourable politicians anywhere in the world?
Politicians, celebrating the UN International Year of Forests in their own special way.
http://www.un.org/en/events/iyof2011/
Indeed they do – the irony is not lost on any of us.
I’m in the Forest of Dean. Our local (Tory) MP, who’s in the government, said unequivocally in our local paper “there are no plans to sell the Forest to commercial interests.” If he’s lying – I’ll sign. Until the the White Paper’s out, I suggest keeping knickers untwisted.
Thanks for that Cyril – when did the Green Paper go out? Isn’t the Green Paper supposed to go out first? What about the Public Bodies Bill clauses 17 & 18 that affects ALL publicly owned forests and is currently in the House of Lords?
*untwists knickers*
A DailyKix Top Story – Trackback from DailyKix.com…
The “Big Society” Forest Sell Off « The Cloud Factory…
[...] Comments « The “Big Society” Forest Sell Off [...]